SOCIETY OF SOVIET UKRAINE AT THE BEGINNING OF GREAT PATRIOTIC WAR: DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC ISSUES

Authors

  • Volodymyr Gula Candidate of Historical Sciences, Union of Archivists of Ukraine member

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.28925/2524-0757.2016.1.11

Keywords:

historiography, Soviet society, social and professional groups, Great Patriotic War

Abstract

The article deals with the formation of historiographical knowledge of Soviet society in the early period of Great Patriotic War. The historiographical researches on this subject are analyzed. The periodizations of historiography of Soviet society in 1941–1942 are defined and explanations of criteria of such periodization are examined. The essential characteristics of each historiographical period and mistakes of some historiographical schools are defined. The priorities of research in the field of study of the history and historiography of Soviet society of the initial period of the Great Patriotic War are defined. The first period in the development of historiography of the initial level of the Great Patriotic War concerning Ukraine falls on 1940–1950s. The characteristics of historiography features of this period are the following: dogmatic views on the events, submission of major conclusions about the war to ideological and political determinants; ignoring negative aspects inherent to Soviet society. The second period covers the events of 1950–1980s. The characteristic features of this period are the following: the creation of a new historical myth of hypertrophied role of parties in the War; the priority development of macro-historical studies; bias of memoir literature; absolutisation of spiritual unity of Soviet society. At the same time, this period characterizes first attempts of critical reflection of the tragic outbreak of war, the role of the Stalinist repressions of the army high command. The third period of Soviet historiography falls on 1980–1990s. This period characterizes a number of contradictory traits. The weakening of ideological censorship and restrictions on open announcements of tragic military confrontation led to the emergence of revisionist historiography direction; empowering access to documentary base of limited access archives created conditions for both objective historical research, and overtly speculative publications. Excessive politicization of historical science has caused the appearance of two vectors — traditional and revisionist. Post-Soviet historiography is based on the recognition of the many achievements of Soviet historiography, on the critics of separate provisions (dogmatism, the principle of partisanship, omission of certain negative aspects of the CPSU (b), government security forces). The Ukrainian state of the development of historiography problems covers a timeframe from 1991 to nowadays. This process is marked by a wide range of pluralistic views on our recent past and a number of features, at first, an attempt to create its own national historical narrative by a fundamental reassessment of the past. Thus, the study of Soviet society in the beginning of the Great Patriotic War was carried out within the conventional scheme: social and professional substructure, society and government, USSR armed forces, which can be explained by errors of Soviet sociology, which actually denied the existence of antagonistic groups in the USSR society. From the present point f view, the study of historiography of Soviet society allows the consideration of this phenomenon in two interrelated dimensions. Firstly, it is an argued comprehensive analysis of Soviet historiography,
the rejection of nihilistic attitude to its heritage. Secondly, the widespread involvement of foreign historiography, especially the one, which uses German archives and oral sources of the European origin, that will be useful in the verification of certain interpretations of the life of Soviet society of 1941–1942.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Aniskov V.T. Podvig sovetskogo krestyanstva v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne: istoriografi cheskiy ocherk / V.T. Aniskov — M. : Mysl, 1979. — 151 s.

Artemyev A.P. Bratskiy boyevoy soyuz narodov SSSR / A.P. Artemyev. — M : Mysl, 1975. — 199 s.

Belyakov A.P. Istoriografi ya trudovogo podviga sovetskogo rabochego klassa v period Velikoy Otechestvennoi voyny: nekotoryye problemy istorii sovetskogo obshhestva (istoriografi ya) / A.P. Belyakov. — M. : Nauka, 1964. — 135 s.

Berkhof K. Zhnyva rozpachu / K. Berkhof. — K. : Krytyka, 2011. — 455 s.

Bradenberger D. Nacional-bolshevizm : stalinskaya massovaya kultura i formirovaniye russkogo natsionalnogo samosoznaniya (1931–1956). Gl. 3. Vozniknoveniye russotsentrichnogo etatizma [Elektronnyy resurs] / D. Branderberger. — Rezhym dostupa : http://lib.rus.ec/b/391980/read

Byulleten nemetskoy armii ot 14 yanvarya 1941 g. [Elektronnyy resurs]. — Rezhym dostupa : http://rkka.ru/idocs.htm

Velikaya Otechestvennaya voyna 1941–1945 godov : v 12 t. / [gl. red. toma V.A. Zolotarev, red.: A.M. Sokolov (zam. gl. red.), V.G. Kulikov (otv. sekretar) i dr.]. — M. : Voyenizdat, 2011. — T. 1 : Osnovnyye sobytiya voyny. — 848 s.

Vert A. Rossiya v voyne. 1941–1945 / A. Vert ; [per. s angl.]. — M. : Progress, 1967. — 774 s.

Grakina E.I. Uchenyye — frontu. 1941–1945 / E.I. Grakina. — M. : Nauka, 1989. — 256 s.

Hrynevych V. Suspilno-politychni nastroi naselennia Ukrainy v roky Druhoi svitovoi viiny: istoriohrafi chni notatky / V. Hrynevych // Problemy istorii Ukrainy: fakty, sudzhennia, poshuky. — 2007. — № 16. — S. 405–434.

Hula V.D. Pochatok naukovoho vyvchennia radianskoho suspilstva 1941–1942 rr. : radianska istoriohrafi ia 1960-kh rr. // Ukraina u svitoviy istorii. — 2014. — № 3. — S. 152–160.

Hula R.V. Vytoky ta rol radyanskoho patriotyzmu u roky Velykoi Vitchyznianoi viiny 1941–1945 rr. (na materialakh Ukrainy) / R.V. Hula. — D. : Herda, 2013 — 516 s.

Gusev M.I. Stalnyye puti Donbassa / M.I. Gusev, A.I. Maksimov i dr. ; [pod red. V.V. Priklonskogo]. — Donetsk : Donbass, 1970. — 336 c.

Dunayeva N.P. Rabochiy klass SSSR perioda Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyny v sovetskoy istoriografi i : avtoref. dis. na soisk. uch. st. kand. ist. nauk / N.P. Dunayeva. — M., 1979 — 20 s.

Zubkova E. Poslevoyennoye sovetskoye obshhestvo: politika i povsednevnost. 1945 — 1953 / E. Zubkova. — M. : ROSSPEN, 1999. — 229 s.

Iz istorii sovetskoy intelligentsii. — M. : Mysl, 1966. — 223 s.

Istoriografi ya istorii Ukrainskoy SSR / pod. red. I.S. Hmelya. — K. : Naukova dumka, 1987. — 557 s.

Istoriya vtoroy mirovoy voiny. 1939–1945 : [v 12 t.] — M. : Voyenizdat, 1975. — Tom 3. Nachalo voiny. Podgotovka agressii protiv SSSR — 503 c.

Istorija vtoroy mirovoy voiny. 1939–1945 : [v 12 t.] — M. : Voyenizdat, 1975. — T. 4: Fashistskaya agressiya protiv SSSR. Krakh strategii «molnienosnoy voiny» — 536 c.

Istoriya Latvii: obrazovaniye, pamyat, issledovaniye [Elektronnyy resurs] // Ministerstvo inostrannykh del Latviyskoy respubliki. Dekabr 2001 g. — Rezhym dostupa : http://www.latviaspb.ru/ru/presse/history/280/

Kurnosov Yu.A. Kultura Ukrainskoy SSR na sluzhbe fronta // Sovetskaya kultura v gody Velikoy Otechestvennoy voiny / Yu.A. Kurnosov. — M. : Nauka, 1976. — S. 155–172.

Kurnosov Yu.O. U navchanni ta pratsi: pidhotovka kadriv intelihentsii v Ukrayinskii RSR / Yu.O. Kurnosov, A.H. Bondar. — K. : Naukova dumka, 1964. — 343 s.

Ladyvir I.I. Vklad uchenykh AN URSR u peremohu nad fashystskoiu Nimechchynoiu / I.I. Ladyvir. — K. : Naukova dumka, 1970. — 175 s.

Maksakova L.V. V ryadakh voyuyushchego naroda / L.V. Maksakova. — M. : Mysl, 1965. — 310 s.

Mirovyye voiny XX veka : v 4 kn. — Kn. 3: Vtoraya mirovaya voina: istoricheskiy ocherk / otv. red. E.N. Kulkov. — M. : Nauka, 2002. — 595 s.

Mitrofanova A.V. Rabochiy klass SSSR v nachalnyi period Velikoy Otechestvennoy voiny / A.V. Mitrofanova. — M. : Izd-vo Akad. Nauk SSSR, 1960. — 486 s.

Obshhestvo i vlast, 1930-e gody: povestvovanie v dokumentakh. — M. : ROSSPEN, 1998. — 352 s.

Patryliak I. Ukraina v roky Druhoyi svitovoi viiny: sproba novoho kontseptualnoho pohliadu / I. Patryliak, M. Borovyk. — Nizhyn : Vydavets PP Lysenko M.M., 2010. — 590 s.

Perekhrest O.H. Ukrayinske selo v 1941–1945 rr : ekonomichne ta sotsialne stanovyshche / O.H. Perekhrest. — Cherkasy : ChNU im. B. Khmelnytskoho, 2011. — 668 s.

Politychna istoriia Ukrainy. XX st. : [v 6 t.] / [red. kol.: I.F. Kuras (holova) ta in.]. — T. 4 : Ukraina u Druhii svitovii viini (1939–1945) / ker. tomu V.I. Kucher. — K. : Heneza, 2003. — 584 s.

Rokovyye resheniya: [vospominaniya nemetskikh voenachalnikov o Vtoroy Mirovoy voine]. — M. : Voyenizdat, 1958. — 607 s.

Savelev V.M. Sovetskaya intelligentsiya v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voine / V.M. Savelev, V.P. Savvin. — M. : Mysl, 1974. — 285 s.

Salata O. Vnesok Ukrayiny u zmitsnennia materialno-tekhnichnoi bazy SRSR v period oboronnykh boiv (22 chervnia — hruden 1941 r.) / O. Salata. — K., 2004. — 222 c.

Socialnoye razvitiye sovetskoy intelligentsii. — M. : Nauka, 1986. — 335 s.

Davies J. Mission to Moscow [Elektronnyy resurs] / J. Davies. — N. Y., 1941. — Rezhym dostupu : http://www.imdb.com/media/rm2051903232/tt0036166

Didier F. Ich sah den Bolschewismus. Dokumente der Wahrheit gegen die Bolschewistische Lüge / F. Didier. — Weimar, 1942. — 463 s.

Ressing К. Jungarmisten der Weltrevolution: Der Verrat des Bolschewismus an der Jugend / К. Ressing. — Nurnberg, 1942. — 64 s.

Seaton A. Th e Russo-German War 1941–1945 / A. Seaton. — L. : ARTHUR BARKER, 1971. — 628 р.

Strong A. Th e Stalinera [Електронний ресурс] / A. Strong. — NY, 1945. — Режим доступу : http:// www.worldcat.org/title/stalin-era/oclc/297634658

The Russian Front: Germany’s War in the East 1941–1945. — L., Armsand Armour Press, 1978. — History. — 184 p.

Downloads


Abstract views: 697

Published

2016-06-02

How to Cite

Gula, V. (2016). SOCIETY OF SOVIET UKRAINE AT THE BEGINNING OF GREAT PATRIOTIC WAR: DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC ISSUES. Kyiv Historical Studies, (1 (2), 87–96. https://doi.org/10.28925/2524-0757.2016.1.11

Issue

Section

History of Ukraine